Buffalo Nickels – Page 4 – Treasure Hunter Co

1-2 day fast, worldwide shipping!

4.8 star average reviews on over 50,000+ sales!

Authentic: Coins, Antiques, and People

Let customers speak for us

from 173 reviews

I LOVE YOUR PRODUCTS And WILL CONTINUE AS A CUSTOMER!

Ruben Fuentes

11/10/2026

I Love the product so much its an amazing piece of history!

Thank you for the service as you'll the BEST!

Respectfully

Ruben Fuentes

Ruben Fuentes

11/10/2026

1899 Large Silver Certificate 1 Dollar Black Eagle Note - Fine (F) - Teehee/Burke Signatures - Rare 1899 One Dollar Silver Note - Fr#233

Just what needed to complete the collection. Thanks

Anonymous

11/09/2026

1909 Indian Head Penny - VG-F (Very Good to Fine) Grade / Condition - 1909 Indian Head Cent - 1909 Penny - 1909 Cent

Great purchase my kids loved it.

Anonymous

11/09/2026

Ultimate Bag of US Coins - Morgan Silver Dollars - Silver Dimes, Half Dollars, Quarters - Buffalo / V Nickels, Indian Head & Wheat Cents

I love the keys that I received! Customer service was great and I received my keys promptly.

Anonymous

11/09/2026

Antique Skeleton Keys! - Awesome for Décor, Craft Projects, Jewelry Projects - Vintage Keys, Real Old Keys from the 1800s

Everything ordered arrived quickly and accurately

Thomas

11/07/2026

1872 Half Dime - VG - 1872 Seated Liberty Half Dime - Early American Coin

Excellent vendor

Anonymous

11/06/2026

1810 Large Cent - G Details (Good) - Rare, Great Type Coin - US Large Cent 1810 One Cent US - Great Type Coin

Nice piece great feeling just to own it

Anonymous

11/06/2026

1935-S Walking Liberty Silver Half Dollar - Choose By Grade - San Francisco Mint- Half Dollar 1935 S Wlh 1935S

Im glad that this coin i bought from this store is well preserved and retained its collectible value. It was delivered in time and came secured. Will buy from this store again and again.

Nephtali Lindo

11/06/2026

1918 German Bonn and Sieg 5 Pfennig - Notgeld Emergency Coinage - WWI Token - Rhine Bridge Bonn

WOW what a perfect piece. Thanks. Dennis

Dennis Brennan

11/02/2026

1909-S Indian Head Penny - Very Rare, Key Date - XF - 1909 S Us One Penny - 1909 S Mint Indian Head Cent 1909 S Mark

Another great piece.

Anonymous

11/01/2026

1919-S Walking Liberty Half Dollar - Choose by Grade - Silver Half Dollar - San Francisco Mint 1919 S WLH 1919 S Half Dollar

See my note

Anonymous

10/28/2026

1976 United States Mint Silver Proof Set - 1976 S Proof Set - 1976 S Silver Proof Set - Silver Kennedy Half Silver Quarter Silver Eisenhower

great coins and great for my collectioin.

Johnall Johnson

10/28/2026

1971-1978 Eisenhower Silver and Clad Dollars - BU (Uncirculated), Proofs - Choose by Date & Type, 1971-S Eisenhower Silver Dollar

What am I reveiwing?

Johnall Johnson

10/27/2026

great coin and just what I was looking for my collection

Johnall Johnson

10/27/2026

1931-D Wheat Penny - Choose by Grade - Denver Mint 1931 Wheat Ear Cent - Semi-Key Date Wheat - Key date of the 1930's