Buffalo Nickels – Treasure Hunter Co

Skip to content

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Have an account?

Log in to check out faster.

Your cart

Loading...

Subtotal

$0.00 USD

Tax included and shipping calculated at checkout

View Cart

20,000+ Products Shop Now

Fastest Shipping Shop Now

Exclusive Products Shop Now

United States Coins
- U.S. Small Cents
  
  Flying Eagle Cents
  Indian Head Cents
  Wheat Penny Cents
  Memorial Penny Cents
  Civil War Tokens
- U.S. Large Cents
  
  Drapped Bust (1796-1807)
  Classic Head (1808-1814)
  Liberty Head (1816-1857)
- U.S. Dimes & Half Dimes
  
  Half Dimes
  Liberty Seated Dimes
  Barber Dimes
  Mercury Dimes
  Roosevelt Dimes
- U.S. Two Cents/ Three Cents
  
  Two Cents
  Silver Three Cents (Trimes)
  Nickel Three Cents
- U.S. Nickels
  
  Shield Nickels
  Liberty Head V Nickels
  Buffalo Nickels
  Jefferson Nickels
- U.S. Quarters
  
  Seated Liberty Quarters
  Barber Quarters
  Standing Liberty Quarters
  Washington Quarters
- U.S. Half Dollars
  
  Draped Bust/ Half Bust Half Dollars
  Seated Liberty Half Dollars
  Barber Half Dollars
  Walking Liberty Half Dollars
  Franklin Half Dollars
  Commemorative Half Dollars
- U.S. Silver Dollars
  
  Trade Dollars
  Morgan Dollars
  Peace Dollars
Worldwide Coins
- Canada
  
  Canada
  Newfoundland
- Mexico
- Europe
  
  United Kingdom
  Ireland
  Germany
  France
  Italy
- South America
- Australia and New Zealand
Paper Currency
- U.S. Paper Currency
  
  Federal Reserve Notes
  U.S. Legal Tender Notes
  Silver Certificates
  Obsolete Currency
  Fractional Notes
  Colonial Currency
  Confederate States Of America
- Worldwide Paper Currency
  
  Canada
Tokens/Exonumia
Jewelry & Others
Collections, Sets, & Proofs

Language

Language

English
Deutsch
Nederlands
Português (portugal)
Русский
বাংলা
हिन्दी
日本語
한국어
Tiếng việt
Polski
Italiano
ภาษาไทย
العربية
Čeština
Svenska
Ελληνικά
Українська
Türkçe
Español

Facebook
Instagram
TikTok
YouTube

United States Coins
- U.S. Small Cents
  
  Flying Eagle Cents
  Indian Head Cents
  Wheat Penny Cents
  Memorial Penny Cents
  Civil War Tokens
- U.S. Large Cents
  
  Drapped Bust (1796-1807)
  Classic Head (1808-1814)
  Liberty Head (1816-1857)
- U.S. Dimes & Half Dimes
  
  Half Dimes
  Liberty Seated Dimes
  Barber Dimes
  Mercury Dimes
  Roosevelt Dimes
- U.S. Two Cents/ Three Cents
  
  Two Cents
  Silver Three Cents (Trimes)
  Nickel Three Cents
- U.S. Nickels
  
  Shield Nickels
  Liberty Head V Nickels
  Buffalo Nickels
  Jefferson Nickels
- U.S. Quarters
  
  Seated Liberty Quarters
  Barber Quarters
  Standing Liberty Quarters
  Washington Quarters
- U.S. Half Dollars
  
  Draped Bust/ Half Bust Half Dollars
  Seated Liberty Half Dollars
  Barber Half Dollars
  Walking Liberty Half Dollars
  Franklin Half Dollars
  Commemorative Half Dollars
- U.S. Silver Dollars
  
  Trade Dollars
  Morgan Dollars
  Peace Dollars
Worldwide Coins
- Canada
  
  Canada
  Newfoundland
- Mexico
- Europe
  
  United Kingdom
  Ireland
  Germany
  France
  Italy
- South America
- Australia and New Zealand
Paper Currency
- U.S. Paper Currency
  
  Federal Reserve Notes
  U.S. Legal Tender Notes
  Silver Certificates
  Obsolete Currency
  Fractional Notes
  Colonial Currency
  Confederate States Of America
- Worldwide Paper Currency
  
  Canada
Tokens/Exonumia
Jewelry & Others
Collections, Sets, & Proofs

Language

Language

English
Deutsch
Nederlands
Português (portugal)
Русский
বাংলা
हिन्दी
日本語
한국어
Tiếng việt
Polski
Italiano
ภาษาไทย
العربية
Čeština
Svenska
Ελληνικά
Українська
Türkçe
Español

Search for anything

Home › Buffalo Nickels

Sort by:

65 products

Filter:

Availability (0)

Availability

In stock (53 products)
Out of stock (23 products)

In stock (53 products)
Out of stock (23 products)

Price

The highest price is $10,000.00

$

From

To

Year Filter (0)

Year Filter

1913 (2 products)
1925 (1 product)

1913 (2 products)
1925 (1 product)

Sort by:

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

65 products

Availability

In stock (53 products)
Out of stock (23 products)

Clear

Price

The highest price is $10,000.00

$

From

$

To

Clear

Year Filter

1913 (2 products)
1925 (1 products)

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

65 products

1938-D Buffalo Nickel - Choose by Grade / Condition - Last Year of Production - Denver Mint - 1938-D Nickel - Indian Head Nickel 1938D

1938-D Buffalo Nickel - Choose by Grade / Condition - Last Year of Production - Denver Mint - 1938-D Nickel - Indian Head Nickel 1938D

Regular price From $4.49

Regular price Sale price From $4.49
Unit price per
1936-S Buffalo Nickel - Choose by Grade VF-BU (Very Fine to Uncirculated) - San Francisco Mint - 1936 S Indian Head Nickel 1936 S

1936-S Buffalo Nickel - Choose by Grade VF-BU (Very Fine to Uncirculated) - San Francisco Mint - 1936 S Indian Head Nickel 1936 S

Regular price From $4.00

Regular price Sale price From $4.00
Unit price per
1935-S Buffalo Nickel - VG-AU (Very Good to About Uncirculated) Grades; Choose by Grade San Francisco Mint - 1935 S Indian Head Nickel 1935S

1935-S Buffalo Nickel - VG-AU (Very Good to About Uncirculated) Grades; Choose by Grade San Francisco Mint - 1935 S Indian Head Nickel 1935S

Regular price From $4.00

Regular price Sale price From $4.00
Unit price per
1934 Buffalo Nickel - VF-AU (Very Fine to About Uncirculated) Grades; Choose by Grade - 1934 P Indian Head Nickel 1934 P Nickel

1934 Buffalo Nickel - VF-AU (Very Fine to About Uncirculated) Grades; Choose by Grade - 1934 P Indian Head Nickel 1934 P Nickel

Regular price From $5.00

Regular price Sale price From $5.00
Unit price per
1926 Buffalo Nickel - VG to XF (Very good to Extremely Fine) Grade - Philadelphia Mint - Choose by Grade - 1926 P Nickel Indian Head 1926

1926 Buffalo Nickel - VG to XF (Very good to Extremely Fine) Grade - Philadelphia Mint - Choose by Grade - 1926 P Nickel Indian Head 1926

Regular price From $4.00

Regular price Sale price From $4.00
Unit price per
1924 Buffalo Nickel - VG to XF (Very good to Extremely Fine) Grade; Choose by Grade - Philadelphia Mint - 1924 P Nickel Indian Head 1924

1924 Buffalo Nickel - VG to XF (Very good to Extremely Fine) Grade; Choose by Grade - Philadelphia Mint - 1924 P Nickel Indian Head 1924

Regular price From $4.00

Regular price Sale price From $4.00
Unit price per
1925 Buffalo Nickel - G-VF (Good to Very Fine), Choose by Grade - Vintage US Coin - Buffalo Nickels - 1925 US 1925 Indian Head Nickel 1925

1925 Buffalo Nickel - G-VF (Good to Very Fine), Choose by Grade - Vintage US Coin - Buffalo Nickels - 1925 US 1925 Indian Head Nickel 1925

Regular price From $3.00

Regular price Sale price From $3.00
Unit price per
1923-S Buffalo Nickel - Choose by Grade / Condition - Tougher Date to Find - Indian Head Nickel 1923 S Buffalo Nickel 1923S

1923-S Buffalo Nickel - Choose by Grade / Condition - Tougher Date to Find - Indian Head Nickel 1923 S Buffalo Nickel 1923S

Regular price From $6.00

Regular price Sale price From $6.00
Unit price per
1920 Buffalo Nickel - VG-VF (Very Good to Very Fine) Grade / Condition - Vintage US Coin - Clear Date 1920 Nickel Indian Head Nickel 1920 P

1920 Buffalo Nickel - VG-VF (Very Good to Very Fine) Grade / Condition - Vintage US Coin - Clear Date 1920 Nickel Indian Head Nickel 1920 P

Regular price From $4.00

Regular price Sale price From $4.00
Unit price per
1917 Buffalo Nickel - Choose by Grade - 1917 P Indian Head Nickel 1917-P Buffalo Nickel 1917

1917 Buffalo Nickel - Choose by Grade - 1917 P Indian Head Nickel 1917-P Buffalo Nickel 1917

Regular price From $5.00

Regular price Sale price From $5.00
Unit price per
1916-S Buffalo Nickel - Better Date - G-Vg (Good To Very Good) Choose By Grade - San Francisco Mint 1916 S Buffalo Indian Head Nickel 1916 S

1916-S Buffalo Nickel - Better Date - G-Vg (Good To Very Good) Choose By Grade - San Francisco Mint 1916 S Buffalo Indian Head Nickel 1916 S

Regular price From $9.00

Regular price Sale price From $9.00
Unit price per
1916 Buffalo Nickel - Choose By Grade - 1916 P Buffalo Nickel 1916 Nickel No Mint - Vintage Us Coin

1916 Buffalo Nickel - Choose By Grade - 1916 P Buffalo Nickel 1916 Nickel No Mint - Vintage Us Coin

Regular price From $5.00

Regular price Sale price From $5.00
Unit price per
1938 D Buffalo Nickel - VG - F (Very Good to Fine) Condition - Last Year of Production - Denver Mint - 1938-D Nickel

1938 D Buffalo Nickel - VG - F (Very Good to Fine) Condition - Last Year of Production - Denver Mint - 1938-D Nickel

Regular price $5.00

Regular price Sale price $5.00
Unit price per
1937-S Buffalo Nickel - Vf-Xf (Very To Extremely Fine) Grades; Chose By Grade - San Francisco Mint - Indian Head Nickel 1937 S Nickel

1937-S Buffalo Nickel - Vf-Xf (Very To Extremely Fine) Grades; Chose By Grade - San Francisco Mint - Indian Head Nickel 1937 S Nickel

Regular price From $6.00

Regular price Sale price From $6.00
Unit price per
1937-D Buffalo Nickel - VF-XF (Very to Extremely Fine) Grades; Chose by Grade - Denver Mint - Indian Head Nickel 1937 D Nickel

1937-D Buffalo Nickel - VF-XF (Very to Extremely Fine) Grades; Chose by Grade - Denver Mint - Indian Head Nickel 1937 D Nickel

Regular price From $4.00

Regular price Sale price From $4.00
Unit price per
1936 Buffalo Nickel - VF-AU (Very Fine - About Uncirculated) Grades; Choose by Grade - 1936 Indian Head Nickel 1936 P Nickel Buffalo Reverse

1936 Buffalo Nickel - VF-AU (Very Fine - About Uncirculated) Grades; Choose by Grade - 1936 Indian Head Nickel 1936 P Nickel Buffalo Reverse

Regular price From $4.00

Regular price Sale price From $4.00
Unit price per
1934 D Buffalo Nickel - VG-XF (Very Good to Extremely Fine); Choose by Grade - 1934-D Nickel 1934D Indian Head Nickel 1934 D - Denver Mint

1934 D Buffalo Nickel - VG-XF (Very Good to Extremely Fine); Choose by Grade - 1934-D Nickel 1934D Indian Head Nickel 1934 D - Denver Mint

Regular price From $4.00

Regular price Sale price From $4.00
Unit price per
1935-D Buffalo Nickel - VG-XF (Very Good to Extremely Fine) Grades; Choose by Grade; Denver Mint - 1935 D Indian Head Nickel 1935 D

1935-D Buffalo Nickel - VG-XF (Very Good to Extremely Fine) Grades; Choose by Grade; Denver Mint - 1935 D Indian Head Nickel 1935 D

Regular price From $4.00

Regular price Sale price From $4.00
Unit price per
1930-S Buffalo Nickel - G-VF (Good to Very Fine) Grade - Excellent Date - San Francisco Mint - 1930 S Nickel Indian Head Nickel 1930 S

1930-S Buffalo Nickel - G-VF (Good to Very Fine) Grade - Excellent Date - San Francisco Mint - 1930 S Nickel Indian Head Nickel 1930 S

Regular price From $4.00

Regular price Sale price From $4.00
Unit price per
1929-S Buffalo Nickel - VG-F (Very Good to Fine) - Clear Date - San Francisco Mint - 1929 S Nickel - Vintage US Coin

1929-S Buffalo Nickel - VG-F (Very Good to Fine) - Clear Date - San Francisco Mint - 1929 S Nickel - Vintage US Coin

Regular price $4.00

Regular price Sale price $4.00
Unit price per
1928-S Buffalo Nickel - G-F (Good to Fine) Choose by Grade - 1928 S Indian Head Nickel 1928S Buffalo Nickel 1928 S Nickel

1928-S Buffalo Nickel - G-F (Good to Fine) Choose by Grade - 1928 S Indian Head Nickel 1928S Buffalo Nickel 1928 S Nickel

Regular price From $4.00

Regular price Sale price From $4.00
Unit price per
1927-D Buffalo Nickel - Choose by Grade / Condition - 1927 D Indian Head Nickel 1927D Nickel

1927-D Buffalo Nickel - Choose by Grade / Condition - 1927 D Indian Head Nickel 1927D Nickel

Regular price From $5.00

Regular price Sale price From $5.00
Unit price per
1927-S Buffalo Nickel - G-VG (Good to Very Good) Grade / Condition - 1927-S Indian Head Nickel 1927 S - San Francisco Mint

Sold out

1927-S Buffalo Nickel - G-VG (Good to Very Good) Grade / Condition - 1927-S Indian Head Nickel 1927 S - San Francisco Mint

Regular price $6.00

Regular price Sale price $6.00
Unit price per

Sold out
1928 Buffalo Nickel - Vintage US Coin - Readable Date

1928 Buffalo Nickel - Vintage US Coin - Readable Date

Regular price $4.59

Regular price Sale price $4.59
Unit price per

1
2
3

Subscribe our newsletter

Email

Facebook
Instagram
YouTube
TikTok

Quick Links

Home
Shop
About
Contact Us

Categories

United States Coins
Paper Currency
Proof Sets, Mint Sets, Other Sets Collections

Contact Us

PO Box 1045 Dover NH 03820

support@treasurehunterco.com

Payment methods

© 2025, Treasure hunter co

Refund policy
Privacy policy
Terms of service

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.